Blog

Using AI Didn't Cut These Attorney Fees. Here Is Why.

Using AI Didn't Cut These Attorney Fees. Here Is Why.

Using AI Didn't Cut These Attorney Fees. Here Is Why.

By

By

Hans Guntren

Hans Guntren

·

·

On October 30, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals answered a question every firm that uses AI will hear sooner or later: if AI did part of the work, shouldn't the attorney fees be lower? The losing side in a trade secrets case from Colorado argued that defense counsel should have billed fewer hours because they relied on AI and other online research tools. The court disagreed and affirmed the fee awards in full.

That argument will not stay in commercial litigation. Family law is a practice where a judge regularly decides what one side's fees should be, and the person objecting has every reason to read the billing records line by line.

What the court decided about AI and attorney fees

The opinion is published, written by Judge Carolyn McHugh for a three-judge panel. The defendants had won a dismissal, and a Colorado statute entitled them to fees. The trial court awarded $114,663.11, the full amount requested, and later a supplemental $68,990.50.

On appeal, the plaintiffs gave three reasons the hours were unreasonable. The third was AI. The court's answer was short: "Plaintiffs identify no evidence that counsel's use of AI resulted in excessive billing."

The court did not say AI is irrelevant to fees. It said it is possible that AI and other research tools may reduce the hours research requires, and so lower the fee. Then it pointed to the other half of the job: ethical rules require counsel to verify the cases they cite. Even assuming AI makes lawyers more efficient over time, the plaintiffs had not shown that it made the hours actually spent unreasonable.

What carried the day was the record. The magistrate judge had gone through the billing entries, found that counsel tracked time to the tenth of an hour and did not block bill, and found the hours reasonable. The other side had a theory about AI. The firm had its time entries.

Why this reaches family law firms

In family law, a fee often ends up in front of a judge. California is one example: Family Code section 2030 tells the court to make sure each party has access to representation, by ordering one party to pay the other's fees where the income and needs assessments call for it, in whatever amount is "reasonably necessary." Every such request invites the same objection: they used AI, so it should have taken less time.

I'd be careful about how far this ruling goes. It is one federal appeals court, applying Colorado law, in a business dispute. It does not bind a family court anywhere. But the reasoning is the kind that travels, because it rests on something every fee statute shares: the question is the hours actually spent, and the answer is in the records.

Clients will ask too. Some will assume AI means a smaller bill. The honest answer depends on how you bill, and on what your state's rules say.

Can you bill for the time AI saved?

No. On hourly work, the guidance is consistent.

  • The ABA. Formal Opinion 512, from July 2024, says lawyers who bill by the hour must bill for their actual time. Its example: the 15 minutes spent giving a tool the facts for a draft pleading is billable, and so is the time spent reviewing the draft.

  • New York. The State Bar's AI ethics guidelines, approved by its House of Delegates on October 31, say a lawyer may not bill for the time the work would have taken without the tool. Time spent writing the instructions and reviewing, verifying and revising the output is billable.

  • Alabama. The State Bar's 2026 guidance uses numbers: a draft that takes 10 minutes with AI and would have taken four hours without it cannot be billed as four hours. The review is billable, the way reviewing a junior associate's draft is.

Flat fees are less settled. The ABA opinion says it may be unreasonable to charge the same flat fee when a tool lets you finish much faster. New York's guidelines say efficiency gains alone do not require a reduction, and the fee is judged under all the usual reasonableness factors. If your firm works on flat fees, read your own state's position before you assume either one.

Tool costs are mostly overhead. New York allows an AI charge as a disbursement only when it is incurred for, or reasonably allocable to, that client's matter, the basis is disclosed, and the amount is reasonable. The ABA opinion allows passing through a per-use charge at actual cost, with no markup. Alabama treats subscriptions as overhead unless the client agreed otherwise in writing.

And the hours spent learning a tool you will use regularly are yours, not the client's. The ABA and New York both say so.

What to change in your billing this month

  1. Write time entries that say what a person did. As an example, "Reviewed and corrected AI-assisted draft of declaration; checked each citation against the source" survives a fee objection. "Draft declaration, 0.4" starts one.

  2. Record verification as its own task. The court treated checking the authorities as required work. Make it visible on the bill.

  3. Track to the tenth of an hour, one task per entry. That is what the magistrate judge credited.

  4. Add an AI paragraph to the fee agreement. Say whether the firm uses AI, that hourly time is billed as actually spent, and whether any AI charge will appear as an expense and on what basis. Put it in writing at the start of the matter.

  5. Decide where each tool's cost sits. Overhead, or a per-matter expense. If it is an expense, it has to belong to that matter, be disclosed and be reasonable.

  6. Revisit flat fees once a year. If the work behind a fee has changed, be ready to explain why the fee is still reasonable.

  7. Give staff one sentence for clients. A sample: "We use AI for first passes on drafts and for organizing your documents. You are billed for the time our team actually spends, including checking that work."

Deliberately.ai's Del is priced per matter, from $45 per matter per month with unlimited users, so its cost belongs to a specific case and can be passed through as a case expense. Whether and how you pass it through still depends on your state's rules and your fee agreement. Del does the first pass and your team reviews it, and that review is time your people actually spend. More on how that works is on our page about AI for law firms.

A fee fight about AI will not be won by arguing about what AI can do. It will be decided by what your records show your people did, and by what you told the client on day one. Both are cheap to fix now and expensive to reconstruct later.

If you want to see how Del handles a real matter, you can start a free account. Setup is free.

This article is practical commentary, not legal advice. Fee and billing rules differ by state, so check your own state's rules and ethics opinions.

Related reading: A Law Firm's AI Policy Just Kept It Out of a Sanctions Order · New York's Bar Says Ask Before Your AI Notetaker Records

Related Articles

Posted by

Hans Guntren

Hans Guntren

on

Posted by

Hans Guntren

Hans Guntren

on

Posted by

Hans Guntren

Hans Guntren

on

Posted by

Hans Guntren

Hans Guntren

on

Join the movement transforming legal work.

Join the movement transforming legal work.

Join the movement transforming legal work.

Stay ahead of the curve with practical tools and AI-powered client intelligence designed to help your firm work smarter and serve clients better.

Stay ahead of the curve with practical tools and AI-powered client intelligence designed to help your firm work smarter and serve clients better.

Start Your Free Trial