In March, a California appeals court received a brief in a child support appeal that cited cases that do not exist and quoted language no court wrote. The father who filed it was representing himself. After the mother moved to strike the brief, he said he had drafted it with an AI tool and had not checked the citations, according to the Family Violence Appellate Project's summary of the decision.
Fake citations in an opposing brief used to be someone else's story. In family law, where the other side may have no lawyer, they are now an ordinary risk. And the summaries show something easy to miss: the problem reached the court through the other side's motion.
What the California court decided
The decision came from the First District Court of Appeal, Division Four, on March 19, 2026. The opinion is here, and the California Lawyers Association's family law section summarized it a week later.
Three points matter for a family law office.
The court held the father to the same standard as an attorney for what he filed, even though he had no lawyer.
It extended to self-represented litigants the warning it had already given attorneys: cite only what you have personally read and verified.
It said it could have fined him. In the court's words, as quoted by the California Attorney's Fees blog: "We may impose monetary sanctions pursuant to our own motion for unreasonable violations of the rules governing appeals."
It chose not to. Both summaries give the same two reasons: he admitted the error, and a sanction would not have served the children's best interests.
I think that was the right call. A fine on a parent in a child support case comes out of the same household the case is about. The rule is now clear, and the next litigant has been warned.
Who checks the other side's citations?
Someone on the mother's side read that brief closely enough to move to strike it. That is work nobody planned for, and in a family law office it often lands on the paralegal.
California is not alone. On March 25, Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeal affirmed a ruling in a business dispute where a self-represented party's briefs were, in the court's words, "replete with case citations that either do not exist or fail to support" his arguments. The court gave a warning instead of a sanction, The Florida Bar News reported. A concurring judge wrote of a "seemingly endless deluge of AI-generated drivel submitted by pro se litigants."
Florida has since changed its rules. Since June 15, anyone who signs a filing there represents that "the legal authorities identified exist and are accurately cited," and that applies to attorneys and self-represented litigants alike, according to The Florida Bar News.
So the duty sits with the person who files. The work of catching a failure still lands on the person who reads. I don't see a rule that changes that.
What to do when a brief cites a case you can't find
Here is a first-pass routine for any brief, motion or letter from the other side that cites authority. The attorney decides what to do with the results.
Pull every authority before anyone drafts a response. For each one, check three things: the case exists, it says what the brief claims, and any quoted words appear in it.
Keep a table. One row per citation: where it appears in their brief, whether you found it, whether it supports the point, whether the quote is real. That table becomes the exhibit if the attorney raises it.
Check the record cites too. The father's brief in California also referred to hearings that were not in the record, according to the Family Violence Appellate Project. Match every transcript and exhibit reference.
Tell the attorney the same day. A missing case changes the response, the timeline and possibly the cost to the client.
Describe what you found, not how it happened. "We could not locate this case in any reporter or database" is a fact. "They used ChatGPT" is a guess. Let the court ask the question.
Let the attorney choose the remedy. The options depend on your court: raising it in the response, a motion to strike, a request for fees or sanctions. The Family Violence Appellate Project's practice alert puts it simply: tell the court when the other side relies on cases that do not exist.
Run the same check on your own side
The same table should exist for your own filings, including the ones you inherit.
In another California decision that month, a trial court's order in a pet custody dispute cited two cases that do not exist. One side's lawyer had cited them first. The other side's lawyer then drafted the proposed order and carried the citations into it, so the Court of Appeal held the challenge was forfeited, according to the California Lawyers Association's summary. The lawyer who first cited them was sanctioned $5,000 for relying on fake authority on appeal, and the court sent its opinion to the State Bar. I wrote about that case in our guide to California's SB 574.
A citation you copy from the other side is yours once you sign it. If your firm has no written rule for this, the Delaware decision I wrote about on Monday shows what a written policy is worth.
Where Del fits, and where it doesn't
Del, our AI teammate for family law firms, does not check case citations. I won't pretend it does. What it shares with this routine is the habit underneath it: when Del answers a question about a matter, the source document comes attached, so your team verifies instead of trusting. That is the standard we hold AI for paralegal work to. Del does the first pass, and your team reviews it.
Courts are telling every filer, lawyer or not, to verify. Until that message reaches everyone, the careful side pays for the careless one, in hours. I don't know yet whether courts will start shifting that cost. I do know the firms that log what they find will be the ones able to ask.
If you want to see what a first pass with sources attached looks like on your own matters, start a free trial.
This is practical commentary, not legal advice. Court rules on striking briefs and on sanctions differ by state and by court. Check your own.
Related reading: Hidden Text in a Court Filing Told AI to Take a Side · A Law Firm's AI Policy Just Kept It Out of a Sanctions Order