On October 31, the New York State Bar Association's House of Delegates adopted a set of ethics guidelines for lawyers' use of AI. There are 20 of them. One, Guideline 3B, covers a tool that may already be sitting in your video calls: the AI notetaker. Its message is short. Ask the client first, tell everyone else on the call, and think hard about whether to record at all.
The FindLaw write-up of the guidelines leads with billing, confidentiality and court filings. For a family law firm, I think 3B matters more. An AI notetaker for lawyers is rarely a decision anyone made. It came with the meeting software, someone switched it on, and now it joins every consultation.
Can a lawyer use an AI notetaker on a client call?
Yes, with conditions. The report uses three verbs with care. "Must" marks an obligation that comes from the Rules of Professional Conduct or other law. "Should" marks recommended practice. "May" marks what is permitted. Read Guideline 3B with that in mind:
A lawyer must follow the recording laws of every jurisdiction where a participant on the call is located.
A lawyer should get the client's consent before using an AI tool to record a conversation with the client.
When someone on the call is not a client, the lawyer should, at a minimum, notify each participant before recording begins.
A lawyer must review an AI-made transcript or summary for accuracy before relying on it or acting on it.
The guideline also tells lawyers to weigh what a permanent record does to privilege, confidentiality, discoverability and the candor of the conversation, and to find out whether the vendor uses the content to train its models or passes it to third parties.
Then comes a sentence I did not expect in a report about using AI: "Absent a particular reason to record, the better practice is not to record."
The guidelines are not discipline rules. The report says they do not amend the Rules of Professional Conduct and do not create disciplinary obligations of their own. They explain how the existing rules apply.
New York lawyers have heard this before. In December 2025 the New York City Bar Association's ethics committee issued Formal Opinion 2025-6 on the same subject, and it was firmer on consent. It concluded that clients must be notified, and their consent obtained, whenever an AI system records their calls. Two bar groups in one state have now said the same thing about ten months apart.
Why this lands harder in family law
A first consultation in a divorce or custody matter is one of the most candid conversations a firm will ever have. The client talks about the marriage, the money and the children, sometimes for the first time to anyone outside the family. A notetaker turns that conversation into a new document, usually one that sits on a vendor's servers.
That document can cut both ways. The City Bar opinion points out that a preserved recording could help a client who later relies on advice of counsel, and could also hand an opponent evidence. I wrote last week about a client's ChatGPT chats becoming evidence. A stored transcript of the consultation raises the same question from the firm's side of the table.
Family law calls also cross state lines. The state guideline points to the recording law of each place a participant is sitting, and those laws differ. California's Penal Code section 632, for one, makes it a crime to record a confidential communication without the consent of all parties. Here is a hypothetical. A New York lawyer takes a video call with a client who has moved to California, and the firm's notetaker starts on its own. By the guideline's terms, California's law governs that recording too.
And the person who turns the notetaker on is often not the attorney. It is whoever sets up the meeting. The guidelines say a firm must make sure the work of nonlawyers using AI tools is adequately supervised. A default nobody chose is the opposite of that.
What if the client brings the notetaker?
The state guideline covers the lawyer's own use. The City Bar opinion covers the other direction. Its ideal is that clients agree not to use their own AI tools on calls without telling the lawyer in advance. When a lawyer knows a client is recording with AI, the lawyer should explain the disadvantages. If the client insists, the opinion says attorneys should disclaim responsibility for AI summaries they have not reviewed.
For a legal assistant, that means looking at the participant list before the call starts and saying something when a notetaker appears on it.
What to do this week
Find out what is on. Check every meeting, phone and calendar account at the firm for automatic recording, transcription or summaries. Turn the default off.
Decide when you record, in writing. Add one paragraph to the firm's AI policy: who may turn a notetaker on, for which kinds of calls, where the transcript goes, and when it is deleted.
Ask, and note the answer. A script: "We'd like to use a tool that transcribes this call so we don't miss anything. Is that all right with you?" Say where the transcript will be kept, and only say what is true. If the answer is no, take notes by hand.
Ask where everyone is. Do it before recording starts. It belongs on the first-call checklist.
Read the vendor's terms. Look for training on your content, sharing with third parties, how long recordings are kept and whether you can delete them.
Review before you rely. A summary is a draft. Someone who was on the call reads it before it goes in the file or shapes advice.
Speak up when the client's notetaker joins. A script for staff: "I see a notetaker has joined. Before we start, the attorney would like to talk with you about whether to record this call."
What else is in the New York guidelines?
Three points a small firm should know. On fees, a lawyer may not bill a client for time spent getting generally familiar with an AI tool, and the general cost of the tools is ordinarily overhead. Time actually spent reviewing and verifying the output can be billed. On supervision, reasonable efforts by a firm may include written policies, training and access controls. On clients, a lawyer must explain the firm's AI use when the client asks whether or how AI is being used in the matter.
A file you can find things in
People turn on a notetaker because they are afraid of losing what the client said. That fear is fair. I think more of it comes from files nobody can find anything in than from calls nobody recorded. We built Del, our AI teammate for family law firms, to read the whole matter file, keep a live case summary and answer questions with the source document attached. The attorney still reviews the work. A firm that can find what the client already gave it has less reason to record everything the client says.
The notetaker is the first AI many firms adopted, and few of them ever decided to. New York's bar has now put the decision in writing. Someone at your firm should make it before the next consultation, and the client should get a say.
If you want to see how Del keeps a family law file current, request a demo.
This is practical commentary, not legal advice. Recording laws and ethics rules differ by state, so check your own state's rules.
Related reading: Your Client Asked ChatGPT First. That Chat May Be Evidence. · A Law Firm's AI Policy Just Kept It Out of a Sanctions Order